"As mentioned earlier, I found Perez's flamboyant setting (in B-Bc 5.615) of the popular Marizapalos particularly intriguing (more florid in places than other surviving settings such as those by Guerau, Sanz, de Murcia and preserved in the…"
"Jalovec's indispensable 'Encyclopedia of violin- makers' gives Benoit Fleury's dates as 1751 - 1791 ( no other suitable Fleury candidates are listed) but it also shows a specimen of his label (seemingly…"
"The pieces were originally included in an earlier manuscript copied by Castillion - B-Lc Ms. 245 in about 1706. This ms. includes one additional pieces by Perez - with the title "Air". In the introduction to the later ms. Castillion says…"
"PS. Further to this: I forgot to mention that the peculiar seeming writing may also be to do with ornaments being fully written out - or attempted to be - rather than the more usual shorthand signs.
Has anybody decoded the intriguing works by Perez in this MS collection copied by Castillion (Bibliotheque du Conservatoire Royale Musique Brussels Cote 5.615)? The fullest version of the various attributions of various works in the collection to Perez is against a piece (page 102) 'Passacaille dite Marizapalos' and gives 'par D. Michel Perez /de Zavala Espagnol/1690)'. A good note on the MS by Monica Hall is here…See More
Thank you for this. Yes - I agree with much of what you write and, in particular, about the peculiar and, to my mind, unattractive (truncated/squashed) body shape profile of E.0748 (the Chambure instrument) - but, as you also…"
Thank you for this and your view that the instrument in question may have been built as late as 1600. However the use of much aged wood by the maker working even after this date cannot be ruled out - indeed, your own view suggests…"
"Thanks for Carlos - it certainly reinforces the view some of us first put forward many years ago (including the late Donald Gill, as well as myself) that we need to question the assumption that the instrument (E.0748) was constructed in the…"
"Many thanks for this Monica.
It's interesting you mention that in an article Gonzales says that there's some doubt about the authenticity of the instrument. Others also raised similar concerns - sometimes also around the…"
"Further to this, the dendrochronology and other information you mention in your reply of 23 Oct does not tell us when the instrument was made - merely that it might not have been made before 1376 or before the parchment strip was originally…"
"A general query: has this instrument ever been scientifically dated? By this I mean by objective evidence such as expert dendrochronolgy or similar scientific dating procedures? I understand that there's very limited provenance…"