A network for historic guitars and vihuelas
Sabato 10 maggio - Auditorium Giovanni Arvedi - ore 21.00, ingresso 10 euro Concerto del chitarrista barocco ROLF LISLEVAND con la chitarra Sabionari, 1679 d...
Add a Comment
No - but one thing is certain and that is that there is no evidence at all that baroque guitar was ever strung with octaves on the third course. This is a modern affectation. At least some of the music in Murcia's manuscripts was originally intended for the "French" tuning i.e. with octave stringing on the fourth course only.
I wonder, is there any very precise primary source information on which tuning Murcia used?
First of all - I would use the "French" tuning. Secondly I would play the notes which are actually written - probably by Murcia himself - in the manuscript rather than something which sounds quite alien to my ears and I would aim for a much more delicate sound - particularly in the strumming. The idea that Murcia's music is proto flamenco, Mexican or whatever is a bit wide of the mark. Let me just quote what Alejando Vera says in his edition of Cifras selectas. "The practice...of filling these pieces with percussion instruments (well at least Lislevand didn't do that on this occasion) and other effects emphasizing their popular effects should be the object of further reflection - at least from a historical point of view". etc. etc. etc. Of course there is no reason why anyone shouldn't perform them in any way they like - but I would have thought that the whole point of playing them on an original instrument was to make them sound as they might have done if Murcia was to play them himself. Of course whether the "Sabionari" guitar in its present state is actually a typical "original" 5-course guitar is a highly contentious issue. Don't have time to say more than that at the moment - but I think players need to think a bit more about what they are actually trying to achieve.....
Monica, what would be an appropriate guitar to play Murcia in your opinion?
It may be an awesome performance but I think Santiago de Murcia gets a bit lost in the process. I don't know whether the instrument is still strung with octave stringing on the 3rd course but the strident tone quality and the flamenco style strumming and other effects is not really appropriate for Murcia's music. I am sure Murcia never played a "restored" Stradivarius guitar either.
Amazing!! Thank you Rolf and Jelma for posting this video!
© 2023 Created by Jelma van Amersfoort. Powered by
You need to be a member of Early Guitars and Vihuela to add comments!
Join Early Guitars and Vihuela